By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A new Polish regulation, effective September 1st, 2025, reduces state-funded religion classes in public schools to one hour weekly, down from two, despite Catholic Church objections. The change mandates scheduling these classes at the beginning or end of the school day if participation is not universal, aiming for increased timetable flexibility. The Church denounced the move as unlawful, citing a lack of prior agreement, while the education ministry countered that the alteration concerns class organization, not the subject’s existence itself. This action follows previous, contested changes to religious instruction scheduling, some of which are currently under review by the Constitutional Court.
Read the original article here
Poland’s recent decision to halve the number of weekly religion classes in schools has sparked a lively debate, reflecting a broader shift in societal attitudes towards religious instruction in education. The reduction, bringing the total down to just one hour per week, is a significant step for a country where the Catholic Church maintains considerable influence. Some see this as a long-overdue modernization, bringing Poland’s educational system in line with 21st-century values.
The reactions to this change are diverse and, in some cases, quite passionate. Many believe that religion is a deeply personal matter, a path of self-discovery that shouldn’t be dictated within a structured school curriculum. The idea of “invisible friends,” representing a faith that’s not universally shared, feels out of place in a secular educational setting. They argue that a single hour a week is still excessive, suggesting that further reductions, or even complete removal, are necessary. Several commenters pointed to their own experiences with mandatory religion classes, describing them as pointless or even actively negative during their formative years.
Conversely, some advocate for maintaining religion classes, though not necessarily in their current form. The suggestion is that religious education could be integrated into other subjects, such as history, to offer students a broader understanding of religious influence on historical events, societal norms and the evolution of culture. A focus on the history of religions, free from prescriptive dogma, could provide valuable context and promote critical thinking, rather than indoctrination. This approach acknowledges the significant role religion has played – and continues to play – in shaping global events and cultural practices, deeming this knowledge essential for well-rounded citizens.
The debate extends beyond the scope of Poland itself. Many are questioning why mandatory religion classes persist in various countries, highlighting the contrast between constitutional secularism and the reality of religious instruction in schools. In some instances, the perceived overreach of religious authorities and their political influence is a cause for concern. This influence is seen in the ongoing struggles within certain countries to reform religious instruction within the school system.
Interestingly, many support the idea of a comparative approach to religious education. Such a model wouldn’t focus on a single faith but instead explore a range of beliefs and practices, providing students with a wider lens through which to view religious phenomena and to comprehend its enduring impact on global affairs. This method, they propose, would allow students to develop informed perspectives while promoting tolerance and understanding. This would shift the focus from religious doctrine to a more anthropological lens, examining the role of faith as a significant cultural and historical force throughout the ages.
This move by Poland to reduce religious instruction also reveals a societal shift. Declining Catholic identification in Poland is a clear indicator of changing religious affiliations, suggesting that the mandatory instruction is no longer aligned with the values of an evolving society. In a world grappling with increasing diversity and a move towards greater secularism, the necessity of compulsory religious education in schools remains a contested subject.
However, the issue is far from resolved. The Polish government’s decision to reduce religious classes, while lauded by some, has also been met with resistance from religious institutions who hold substantial political sway and influence. The current compromise represents merely a step in a continuing process, highlighting the inherent tensions between maintaining religious tradition and accommodating the demands of a pluralistic society. This ongoing debate reflects the tension between religious freedom and freedom from religious imposition within educational institutions.
The ongoing discussion underscores the complex interplay between religion, education, and the political landscape. While the reduction in religion classes is a significant step towards modernizing Poland’s educational system, it also highlights the deep-rooted influence of the Catholic Church and the ongoing challenge of reconciling tradition with the evolving needs of a secular society. The journey towards a truly secular education system is a gradual process, one marked by ongoing debate and compromise.