By John Q. Hosedrinker 
A UTair flight from Moscow to Dubai made an emergency landing due to a hydraulic fluid issue, marking the fourth Russian airline incident in 2025 and the second for UTair in a week. This follows a recent trend of technical problems plaguing Russian airlines, attributed to Western sanctions limiting maintenance and parts supply, forcing “cannibalization” of aircraft. The resulting fleet reduction and increased incidents, coupled with a “red flag” designation from the ICAO, highlight significant safety concerns within Russian aviation. These issues are further exacerbated by reported fuel rationing and rising fuel costs.
Read the original article here
The headline, “Fourth Russian Airline Plane Breaks Down Mid-Flight in 2025,” certainly grabs attention. It’s already mid-January, and we’re only twelve days into the year, yet this is the fourth such incident. That’s an average of one every three days. It’s certainly a stark reminder of the challenges facing Russian airlines.
The situation isn’t surprising, given the impact of international sanctions. These sanctions have severely restricted access to essential spare parts and maintenance services, forcing airlines to resort to improvisational repairs. This lack of readily available parts, combined with rising aviation fuel prices—up 30% since March 2022—is creating a perfect storm of maintenance issues. One has to wonder if the reported rise in fuel prices truly reflects the cost of civilian aviation fuel, or if other factors are at play.
It’s interesting that the headline uses the phrase “breaks down” rather than “crashes.” While a mid-flight malfunction is undoubtedly a serious event requiring an emergency landing, it’s crucial to distinguish between a breakdown that leads to a safe landing and a catastrophic crash. The term “breaks down,” while perhaps understating the gravity of the situation, emphasizes that the planes are not necessarily plummeting from the sky, but rather experiencing malfunctions that necessitate immediate intervention. The pilots, however, still face a pucker-inducing moment when they have to announce to their passengers that the plane has suffered a mechanical failure and must return to the airport.
The frequency of these incidents is raising serious questions. While it’s argued that even a significant increase in the rate of incidents from previous years still represents a relatively low percentage of total flights, the ongoing pattern is undeniably concerning. Some might even consider this a modern version of Russian roulette. It’s important to note that the comparison to Russian roulette is a darkly humorous metaphor, not a statistically accurate assessment of the risk. The actual probability of a Russian airline flight experiencing a mid-flight malfunction is likely far lower than the odds in a game of Russian roulette.
Furthermore, there’s a prevailing sentiment that the sanctions’ impact on Russian aviation has been underestimated. While it’s true that many Russian planes still land safely, the increased number of mid-flight breakdowns suggests that the system is operating under significant strain. The narrative that “100% of Russian planes land successfully” feels misleading given these increasing malfunctions. The planes might eventually all reach the ground, but the journeys are becoming increasingly precarious.
The situation highlights the complex interplay between geopolitical tensions, economic sanctions, and the safety of air travel. Whether the current approach to sanctions is adequate, or whether a more forceful strategy was needed earlier, is a matter of ongoing debate. However, the ongoing events underscore the severe consequences of limiting access to essential maintenance and parts for a country’s aviation industry. The fact that Russian airlines are reportedly resorting to scavenging parts from other planes and using makeshift repairs only amplifies the concerns regarding the safety of their operations. The continued occurrence of these incidents suggests that the situation is unlikely to improve in the near future, and 2025 might prove to be a challenging year for Russian aviation.