By John Q. Hosedrinker A 79-year-old resident of Aspira Traditions in Oshawa died from exposure after wandering outside the building on March 31, 2023, and being unable to re-enter due to locked doors. Two employees, Padmini Kisseur and Danika Harrison, are charged with criminal negligence causing death and failing to provide necessaries of life. The woman, described as vulnerable, exited the building around 7:30 p.m. and was found deceased the following morning. The ongoing investigation seeks further information from anyone with relevant knowledge.
Read the original article here
Two employees have been charged in the death of an assisted care resident who tragically perished after being locked outside the building overnight. The circumstances surrounding this devastating event raise serious questions about staffing levels, training, and the overall systemic issues within the assisted care industry. The vulnerability of the victim, described as having some form of dementia, underscores the urgent need for improved safeguards and protocols to prevent similar tragedies.
The limited information available in initial reports leaves many unanswered questions about the exact sequence of events. Was the resident’s exit from the building noticed immediately? Were the employees aware that she was outside? Did they actively prevent her from re-entering? Or were they simply unaware of her absence due to overwhelming workloads and insufficient staffing? The answers to these questions are crucial in determining the level of culpability and the appropriate legal consequences.
The potential for criminal liability is undeniable, but the case also highlights the pressures faced by frontline caregivers in the assisted care sector. Reports suggest significant understaffing and underpayment are commonplace, leading to overworked and stressed employees who are often unable to provide the level of care needed. This chronic under-resourcing creates a dangerous environment where residents, particularly those with cognitive impairments, are at increased risk of harm.
The incident brings to light the realities of “sundowning,” a phenomenon in which dementia patients experience increased confusion and agitation in the late afternoon and evening. This behavior can make it challenging to monitor and supervise residents, even with adequate staffing. Coupled with understaffing, this adds an extra layer of complexity to the already demanding role of caregivers. The resident’s ability to wander undetected and subsequently become locked out underscores the need for robust monitoring systems and frequent, documented checks on residents’ wellbeing.
While assigning blame to individual employees is unavoidable, it’s vital to acknowledge the systemic issues that contributed to this preventable death. The low pay and high demands in the assisted care industry attract limited numbers of qualified applicants. The resulting staffing shortages force existing employees to stretch themselves thin, compromising the quality of care and increasing the risk of accidents. A thorough investigation of the facility’s policies, procedures, and staffing levels will likely reveal patterns of negligence and systemic failures that extended far beyond the two employees who were charged.
The financial incentives of the assisted care industry also need to be re-evaluated. Some facilities prioritize profit maximization over patient well-being, leading to cost-cutting measures that directly impact the quality of care. This could include insufficient staffing, inadequate training, and a lack of investment in safety protocols. The current system often leaves the most vulnerable residents at the mercy of overworked and underpaid staff.
One potential solution lies in increased government regulation and funding. Mandatory staffing ratios, stricter safety protocols, and higher wages for caregivers could significantly improve the quality of care and reduce the risk of incidents like this one. Such changes would require a substantial investment in the industry, which could involve reallocating resources from other areas of the budget. A crucial aspect of finding a solution involves rethinking the current for-profit model that permeates this sector of healthcare. While a completely non-profit model might not be feasible, exploring alternative approaches that prioritize patient well-being over profit would be beneficial.
The tragic loss of life serves as a stark reminder of the urgent need for systemic change. Simply focusing on individual accountability is insufficient to address the underlying issues. A multi-faceted approach that combines improved staffing, enhanced safety protocols, increased funding, and potential regulatory reform is necessary to prevent future tragedies and ensure the safety and well-being of vulnerable residents in assisted care facilities. The profound sadness and anger stemming from this event shouldn’t be lost; instead, they should fuel the drive for meaningful and lasting reforms. The incident forces society to confront uncomfortable truths about the realities of aged care and the immense responsibility we have to protect those most in need.