By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Chris Hedges’ assertion that capitalists should be barred from healthcare systems highlights the inherent issue of commodifying essential services. This critique extends beyond healthcare to encompass numerous societal systems – from transportation and food to education and the environment – all negatively impacted by capitalist control. The article argues that addressing individual symptoms, like reforming healthcare, is insufficient; a systemic challenge to capitalism itself is necessary. Focusing solely on healthcare reform while ignoring the broader capitalist structure is akin to fighting a bully while allowing most of his attacks to continue.
Read the original article here
Capitalism, at its core, prioritizes profit above all else. This isn’t inherently problematic in every sector, but when applied to systems vital for human well-being, it breeds inequity and suffering. The current focus on removing capitalist influence from healthcare is a crucial step, but it’s merely the tip of the iceberg. We need to address the pervasive nature of capitalist control in all aspects of our lives.
The pursuit of profit shouldn’t dictate access to essential resources like housing, food, and clean water. These are fundamental human rights, not commodities to be traded for monetary gain. A system where basic survival is contingent on financial means is inherently unjust and unsustainable. We must transition towards models where these necessities are guaranteed for everyone, regardless of their economic standing.
The argument that capitalism fosters innovation is often raised. While it may be true that competitive markets can spur progress in certain areas, the current system prioritizes profit over genuine societal needs. Innovation driven purely by the potential for financial gain often neglects vital social issues, creating a system where technological advancements coexist with widespread social inequalities. A more just model would prioritize the needs of the many over the enrichment of the few.
Removing the profit motive from essential services is not radical; it’s logical. When profit becomes the primary goal, the quality of the service inevitably suffers. Examples abound in industries where the profit margin is prioritized over the well-being of consumers. The current healthcare system is a prime example of how profit-driven healthcare fails to provide equitable access to care. This failure is not an anomaly, it’s the predictable outcome of prioritizing profit over people. This pattern will continue to repeat in every sector where profit is the primary driver.
Citizens United and the influence of lobbyists are further evidence of the systemic issues inherent in capitalist structures. Money in politics distorts the democratic process, allowing the wealthy and powerful to shape legislation in their favor. This fundamentally undermines the principle of “one person, one vote” and creates a system where the interests of the few eclipse the needs of the many. The solution, therefore, isn’t simply to regulate capitalism; it’s to fundamentally dismantle its influence in the political sphere.
The idea that capitalism is the only viable economic system is a fallacy. Many alternative models exist, offering a more equitable distribution of wealth and resources. The claim that socialism or communism have failed ignores the nuanced realities of their implementation and the considerable external pressures and interference they’ve faced. Moreover, it often ignores successful examples of social democracy, where regulated capitalism prioritizes social well-being alongside economic growth. The path forward isn’t a binary choice between capitalism and a utopian ideal; it’s about thoughtfully designing a system that addresses the fundamental flaws of unfettered capitalism.
The notion that we must accept the status quo because there is no readily available, foolproof alternative is a dangerous and defeatist stance. Addressing the flaws of capitalism requires creative and collaborative solutions, not accepting its inherent injustices. While the transition will require thoughtful planning and potentially significant systemic changes, it is a necessary undertaking if we want to achieve a truly just and equitable society. The alternatives are not to passively accept suffering or embrace systems that have proven to have their own considerable problems.
The belief that capitalism is the only way to create prosperity is a myth propagated to maintain the status quo. While capitalism has undeniably driven economic growth in certain areas, it has also produced staggering levels of inequality and environmental damage. A system that creates vast wealth for a few while leaving millions in poverty is fundamentally flawed. We can and must create alternative systems that prioritize sustainability, equity, and human well-being above the endless pursuit of profit. Ultimately, the choice is not between accepting a system that benefits a select few and embracing chaos. It’s about building a more just and equitable future, where the needs of all people are prioritized over the insatiable hunger of capital.