By John Q. Hosedrinker 
Malala Yousafzai, surprised by the rapid erosion of women’s rights in Afghanistan since the Taliban’s return to power, highlights the dire situation faced by Afghan women. The Taliban’s restrictions, described by the UN as “gender apartheid,” have led to the widespread denial of education and numerous other rights, leaving millions of girls out of school and impacting women’s overall well-being. A new documentary, *Bread & Roses*, showcases the resilience of three Afghan women amidst these hardships, aiming to raise international awareness and pressure for change. Malala emphasizes the need for global support and solidarity with Afghan women actively resisting oppression despite immense challenges. The film highlights both the loss and the enduring hope for freedom among Afghan women.
Read the original article here
Malala’s dismay at the swift erosion of women’s rights in Afghanistan is deeply understandable. The speed with which these rights vanished underscores the fragility of freedom and the constant vigilance required to protect it. It’s a stark reminder that the freedoms we often take for granted are hard-won and easily lost. Looking back, it’s clear that the seeds of this regression were sown long ago, perhaps even decades earlier.
The UN’s condemnation of Afghanistan’s “morality laws” as “gender apartheid” feels inadequate to capture the full horror. The reality for women there is arguably worse, a situation where their rights are demonstrably less than those afforded to animals. This isn’t just a matter of political oppression; the widespread acceptance of child sexual abuse compounds the crisis, a deeply disturbing element often overlooked in the larger conversation. The international community’s response, or lack thereof, is particularly troubling. The UN’s hesitancy to intervene directly, fearing a religious conflict, highlights the complex geopolitical challenges involved.
The claim that 90% of Afghans support these laws is questionable. Even if true, it’s crucial to remember that this support likely doesn’t represent the voices of the millions of Afghan women directly impacted by these oppressive measures. Their opinions were likely not actively sought or even considered. The responsibility for this situation cannot solely be placed on the Taliban’s shoulders; the Afghan army’s swift capitulation without a fight left the women vulnerable and at the mercy of a regime openly hostile to their rights. There is a need for an internal rebellion against the restrictive laws, however, this will require immense courage and a commitment to fight for freedom.
This situation raises serious concerns about the potential for similar regressions in other parts of the world. The alarming parallels with certain historical totalitarian regimes, which consistently target women’s rights first, cannot be ignored. This isn’t simply a distant problem; anxieties regarding declining women’s rights are present in other nations as well. The comparison to the situation in Afghanistan, however, is often misplaced and dismissive of the true severity of the oppression faced by Afghan women. While these anxieties may be present, they are completely different in nature and should not be compared to the systemic oppression in Afghanistan. The importance of a strong stance against any violation of human rights cannot be overstated. Cultural practices should never justify the stripping away of fundamental rights.
The discussion about the hijab complicates the issue. While choosing to wear a hijab should be a personal choice free from coercion, it’s imperative to differentiate between voluntary religious expression and forced adherence to religious dress codes. The choice should not be one dictated by oppression or fear of reprisal. The Taliban’s actions are an extreme version of religious extremism, considered abhorrent even by other Islamist groups. This is not a disagreement between differing interpretations of Islam, but a confrontation between humanity and a brutal, misogynistic regime.
The idea that the international community can simply “fix” Afghanistan is a fantasy. External intervention is unlikely to be successful in the long term. The most effective solution must come from within Afghanistan itself. While outside forces may offer support, ultimately, the Afghan people bear the responsibility of fighting for their own liberation. The focus needs to shift to a practical solution that will not only solve the immediate crisis but also prepare the country for a more just and equitable future. The failure of previous interventions should serve as a sobering reminder of the complexities involved in nation building. However, we must also acknowledge that this is not an impossible task.
Ultimately, the situation in Afghanistan serves as a powerful reminder of the continuous fight for human rights globally, and the urgent need for global cooperation to protect the rights of women and marginalized groups everywhere. The world must stand united to oppose the systematic oppression and discrimination of women, and any other forms of human rights abuses, no matter where they occur. The fragility of freedom necessitates constant vigilance, a commitment to defend those rights, and a concerted effort to ensure that such tragedies are never repeated.