By Matt Underwood As someone who prides themselves on being a moderate, I find it quite intriguing to watch the political landscape unfold as we approach the 2024 election. A crucial element in this unfolding saga is the ability, or I should say, inability, of Donald Trump to retain moderate support. There’s something particularly bewildering and perturbing about watching his waning appeal amongst procrastinating Republicans, independents, and undecided voters—people like me—who were once hopeful that an outsider might inspire change, but have since been disillusioned by the chaotic and divisive behemoth that is the “Trump legacy”.
And the Republican party isn’t helping the cause either. It feels as if they’re hesitating at the edge of an electoral cliff, all the while continuing with a game plan that has proven, time and time again, to be both toxic and unsuccessful. It seems to me that they have become so engrossed in this Trump-induced mirage that they have lost sight of what the party once stood for—conservative principles, fiscal responsibility, law and order—and what a moderate voter might find appealing.
Why should I, as a moderate, be expected to hitch my wagon to a party that not only condoned but championed a man whose actions undermined the very foundations of our democracy? How could I vote for a party that remains enthralled by a man facing 91 felonies across four indictments? And I’m certainly not the only moderate put off by such damning facts.
Looking at the landscape through a historical lens only amplifies my concerns. Andrew Jackson’s tenure is reminiscent of the Trump era in its incitement of chaos, scandals, and overall deterioration of political courtesy. It was one term in history noted for its inflammable and divisive atmosphere much like the one we are grappling with today. It seems Trump has been taking notes from the less admirable aspects of our history to script his own legacy. An action that is destined to plunge not just Trump, but also the entirety of the Republican party, into a quagmire from which there might be no return.
Amidst these eerie echoes of history and the present-day political circus, my definition of “moderate”—one who wishes for a sensible, incremental approach to resolving urgent issues rather than pandering to far-right or left-wing ideologies—seems to be lost. I crave the kind of political leader who can ensure safety, well-funded education, equality of outcome, and show a human touch at our borders. This isn’t an impossible ask. But the Trump-dominated Republican party has been miles away from meeting these expectations.
As someone who had the mantra of “best person for the job” guiding my voting decisions, the past few years have seen a shift. My stance has been nudged—no, pushed—towards “blue no matter who.” Perhaps I’ve witnessed one too many instances of moral cowardice from the Republicans. Perhaps it’s the devastating effect of the past administration that has led me to this conviction. However, my inner core—anchored firmly in moderation, civility, and rationality—yearns for a return to informed, considerate leadership rather than zealot-led demagoguery.
But it’s important to remember what might be one of the most critical aspects of our democratic process—voting. The drumbeats of an approaching election grow louder each day. And as much as the writing seems to be on the wall regarding Trump’s fading appeal and the consequential Republican meltdown, nothing is set in stone. The only way to ensure that we don’t repeat the mistakes of our recent past is to make our voices heard through our votes. Whether you’re a disillusioned former Trump supporter, an independent voter, or a moderate like me who’s seen enough, it’s time to step up.
While Trump’s prospects look increasingly dire, I remain watchful and wary. I am knowledgeable enough to know that the landscape could shift, and complacency could be our greatest enemy yet. However, I find comfort in clinging onto the words of Scott Simeone, a former Trump supporter: “I can’t vote for Trump. He’s a crook. He’s too corrupt.” Let’s hope the impending election resonates with Simeone’s sentiment and reflects the will of the moderate majority – those who desire stability, progress, and a sense of unity we have long been deprived of. For now, all we can do is watch as the Republican party spins in a Trump-induced dervish, unmoored from its principles, and seemingly untroubled by its loss of moderate support. It’s a spectacle that is as perplexing as it is worrying. However, one sentiment seems to be increasingly clear: The moderates are breaking away. This could cost Trump the 2024 elections—a possibility that brings a measure of cautious optimism for the future.
Looking ahead, as we walk the tightrope straddling the chasm between political chaos and potential calm, let’s ensure we nudge our polity away from the precipice of divisiveness. As moderates, independents, or anyone who cares about the survival of democracy—it’s imperative we stay vigilant. Let’s turn the tide by voting wisely, choosing reason over rhetoric, peace over polarisation, and unity over unprecedented discord. So here’s to hoping that come 2024, the voice of the moderates helps chart a more secure, sensible, and united course for our beloved nation.